Forum Message

Topic: Reinfection
Posted by: Andy Jones
Date/Time: 01/05/20 09:57:00

Not sure I understand the criticism of the WHO. Their stance on the possibility of reinfection seems totally consistent with everyone I have spoken to about the issue.

Most viruses provide some level of immunity from them once you have caught them but this can be variable. There isn't sufficient research on it at the moment and it would be a disaster if health services were to operate on the basis that staff who had had it could come back to work with no risk to them or their patients and then it emerged that there was no immunity.

The latest word from South Korea seems encouraging in that they are now considering cases they had considered to be reinfections as relapses. It would be fantastic news if those infected did have a high level of immunity but the WHO has not made a mistake on being cautious about this.

If any mistake has been made it was by the British government in their early belief in the use of herd immunity as a tool to tackle the outbreak. Thankfully the policy was ditched before too much damage was done.


Entire Thread
TopicDate PostedPosted By
Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?27/03/20 14:07:00 Tricia Arbuthnot
   Re:Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?27/03/20 14:20:00 Simon Hayes
      Re:Re:Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?07/04/20 10:27:00 Oswald Whittle
         Re:Re:Re:Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?07/04/20 17:16:00 Simon Hayes
            Re:Re:Re:Re:Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?30/04/20 12:43:00 James Putland
   Reply27/03/20 14:26:00 N V Brooks
      Reply27/03/20 16:30:00 Gordon Southwell
         Re:Reply27/03/20 16:48:00 Susan Kelly
   Re:Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?27/03/20 17:29:00 Nick Goodliffe
      Re:Re:Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?27/03/20 20:39:00 Peter Chadburn
         Re:Re:Re:Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?07/04/20 21:14:00 Philippa Bond
            Re:Re:Re:Re:Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?09/04/20 10:15:00 Tricia Arbuthnot
               Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?09/04/20 12:33:00 Peter Chadburn
                  Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Is it wrong to hope Trump gets COVID-19?11/04/20 16:37:00 Vlod Barchuk
                     Hopefully we will know soon if Hydroxychloroquine really works or not and how well it works11/04/20 20:52:00 Mark Julian Raymond
                        Slight correction and amplification11/04/20 22:02:00 Mark Julian Raymond
                           Re:Slight correction and amplification12/04/20 07:04:00 Nicholas Beard
                        Re:Hopefully we will know soon if Hydroxychloroquine really works or not and how well it works12/04/20 06:53:00 Nicholas Beard
                           Working U.K. vaccine by September, then how to manufacture it12/04/20 11:57:00 Mark Julian Raymond
   Trump is a pseud09/04/20 21:06:00 Mark Julian Raymond
   Is it wrong to hope Tricia and other posh lefties get it ?14/04/20 05:36:00 Dennis Brogan
      Re:Is it wrong to hope Tricia and other posh lefties get it ?15/04/20 08:10:00 Tricia Arbuthnot
         More nonsense from Tricia !16/04/20 07:12:00 Dennis Brogan
            Re:More nonsense from Tricia !16/04/20 11:14:00 Mark Julian Raymond
               Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !16/04/20 17:18:00 Philippa Bond
                  Re:Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !16/04/20 17:39:00 Rosco White
                     Re:Re:Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !16/04/20 20:50:00 Philippa Bond
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !16/04/20 21:26:00 Rosco White
                           Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !17/04/20 10:44:00 Philippa Bond
                  Re:Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !17/04/20 00:29:00 Rosco White
                     Re:Re:Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !17/04/20 10:32:00 Andy Jones
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !17/04/20 13:17:00 Rosco White
                           PS - Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !17/04/20 14:31:00 Rosco White
                              Re:PS - Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !17/04/20 15:04:00 Andy Jones
                                 Re:Re:PS - Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:More nonsense from Tricia !17/04/20 19:41:00 Peter Chadburn
                                    I like the sound of Remdesivir18/04/20 20:44:00 Mark Julian Raymond
                                       Re:I like the sound of Remdesivir18/04/20 22:47:00 Peter Yale
                                        Sadly Remdesivir fails trial24/04/20 00:39:00 Mark Julian Raymond
   Reply24/04/20 10:17:00 N V Brooks
      Dangerous and weird, Coronavirus detected on particles of air pollution24/04/20 20:42:00 Mark Julian Raymond
         Re:Dangerous and weird, Coronavirus detected on particles of air pollution25/04/20 06:33:00 Nicholas Beard
      Re:Reply24/04/20 21:06:00 Rosco White
         Re:Re:Reply25/04/20 12:51:00 Andy Jones
            Re:Re:Re:Reply25/04/20 15:49:00 Vlod Barchuk
            Re:Re:Re:Reply25/04/20 16:37:00 Rosco White
               Reply25/04/20 17:14:00 N V Brooks
                  You can catch Covid-19 MORE than once - I feel sorry for recovered NHS workers27/04/20 13:04:00 Mark Julian Raymond
                     Re:You can catch Covid-19 MORE than once - I feel sorry for recovered NHS workers27/04/20 17:20:00 Rosco White
                        Re:Re:You can catch Covid-19 MORE than once - I feel sorry for recovered NHS workers27/04/20 17:36:00 Andy Jones
                           Re:Re:Re:You can catch Covid-19 MORE than once - I feel sorry for recovered NHS workers27/04/20 22:05:00 Rosco White
                              See Dr. Birx's reaction to Trump's dangerous suggestion27/04/20 22:29:00 Mark Julian Raymond
                                 Reply28/04/20 09:26:00 Gordon Southwell
                                    Re:Reply28/04/20 15:02:00 Rosco White
                                       Reply28/04/20 16:18:00 Gordon Southwell
                     Don't believe the WHO29/04/20 10:03:00 Vlod Barchuk
                        Re:Don't believe the WHO29/04/20 14:41:00 Peter Evans
                        It is hard to know WHO to believe about re-infection (no pun intended). C.f. face masks29/04/20 15:20:00 Mark Julian Raymond
                           Re:It is hard to know WHO to believe about re-infection (no pun intended). C.f. face masks30/04/20 13:13:00 Rosco White
                              PS - Sunlight and Covid.30/04/20 14:40:00 Rosco White
                                 Like a phoenix from the ashes, Remdesivir now shows promise in Coronavirus treatment 30/04/20 17:00:00 Mark Julian Raymond
                                    Reinfection01/05/20 09:57:00 Andy Jones
                                       Re:Reinfection01/05/20 10:25:00 Vlod Barchuk
                                       Re:Reinfection01/05/20 10:30:00 Vlod Barchuk
                                          Re:Re:Reinfection01/05/20 11:06:00 Andy Jones

Forum Home