Forum Message

Topic: Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims
Posted by: Andy Jones
Date/Time: 23/05/13 20:53:00

'The IRA and its' predecessor organisations were 100% Catholic, of this there is no doubt.'

I'm afraid there is. Many of the predecessor organisations were founded by Protestants like Wolf Tone. In the early part of the 20th Century some of the most prominent members of the Irish Republican movement were Protestant for instance Erskine Childers and Roger Casement. The IRA was always careful to be non-denominational and did have Protestant members right up to the end of the conflict. The Irish flag is meant to signify peace between the green and the orange i.e. that all religions had a stake in an independent Ireland. The IRA was a nationalist organisation that happened to come from a predominantly Catholic country so its membership was largely from that part of the community but it cannot be said that it was a Catholic organisation following Catholic aims.

Many of its senior members were not Catholic for instance Martin McGuinness who was an atheist. The INLA was avowedly anti-clerical and hostile to the Catholic Church. The Church was uniformly against an armed struggle even during the War of Independence and as an institution was indifferent to who had control of Ireland.


Entire Thread
TopicDate PostedPosted By
Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 11:14:00 Jean F Fernandez
   Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 11:24:00 Leslie Bailey
   Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 11:25:00 Nigel Brooks
   Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 11:25:00 Andy Vaughan
      Re:Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 11:36:00 Bud Richards
      Re:Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 11:47:00 John Totes
         Re:Re:Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 11:50:00 Bud Richards
         Re:Re:Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 18:18:00 Tony Colliver
   Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 11:46:00 Paul Laverack
      Re:Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 12:10:00 Jean F Fernandez
         Re:Re:Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 13:44:00 Os A Whittle
         Re:Re:Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?23/05/13 13:45:00 Susan Kelly
   why pick on muslims23/05/13 15:57:00 Asha Smith
      Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 16:14:00 Andy Vaughan
      Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 17:42:00 Chris Veasey
         Re:Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 17:51:00 Nigel Brooks
            Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 18:01:00 Andy Jones
               Re:Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 18:10:00 Nigel Brooks
                  Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 19:28:00 Susan Kelly
                  Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 20:53:00 Andy Jones
                     Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 21:06:00 Chris Veasey
               Re:Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 18:13:00 Chris Veasey
                  Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 20:32:00 Andy Jones
                     Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 21:03:00 Chris Veasey
                        Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims24/05/13 06:10:00 Andy Jones
            Re:Re:Re:why pick on muslims23/05/13 23:00:00 David Wright
   Re:Murder in Woolwich - should the Police be armed?24/05/13 08:06:00 Chris Veasey

Forum Home